(This was my submission for the Internal Assessment for the Feature and Opinion course)
What is a teacher? I asked a teacher as to what they think a
teacher is. The reply was, “someone who has lessons planned for the next two
weeks, but has no clue about that night’s dinner.”
In 1994, UNESCO proclaimed 5th October as World
Teachers Day. This celebrated a great step for teachers as on 5th October 1966,
a special intergovernmental conference in Paris adopted the UNESCO/ILO
Recommendation concerning the Status of Teachers
Countries like Maldives and The Netherlands observe teachers
day on 5th October itself. Countries like India (5th
September) have their own respective teachers days.
The movies have made us laugh and made us cry. They have
given us portrayals of teachers that we relate to and love and respect. In
today’s day and age we wish we had more teachers like them.
Here are some of the best teacher portrayals in movies. As
the efforts of one teacher cannot undermine the efforts of another, the numbers
do not determine the ranking.
I stand upon my desk to remind myself that we must constantly look at things in a different way.
John Keating or O Captain, my Captain (as he wishes to be
called) says, “Because I love teaching, I don’t want to be anywhere else.” This
shows us an essential quality of a teacher- passion.
John Keating aims to help his students to seize the day and
live. It is something that doesn't happen in today's rat race. Teachers like
him are a precious commodity.
Mr Keating encourages his students to rip out an entire
chapter from a book.
The pages contain an introduction by Dr Pritchard. This
introduction seeks to measure poetry based on a graph. According to Keating,
measuring poems is similar to armies of academics annihilating the hearts and
souls of young ones. Poems can’t be measured. They are filled with passion and
are straight from the heart.
In his classes he encourages the students to think for
themselves again. Oh how we yearn for such teachers in a world where our
original ideas are quashed like bugs, these ideas which if allowed to bloom
could change the world or help us be unique. He compares each person’s life as
a verse, and how would everyone be unique if they were all the same?
The final scene symbolises wat a teacher can do. A teacher
can be the match that lights a fire. The match can be extinguished, but the
fire will spread.
2. Anne Bancroft as Anne Sullivan
(The Miracle Worker)
‘The Miracle Worker’ is based on Hellen Keller’s
autobiography, ‘The Story of My Life’. It chronicles the efforts taken by Anne
Sullivan to teach alphabets and their meaning to Hellen Keller.
In ‘The Story of My Life’, Helen Keller writes a tribute to
her teacher, Anne Sullivan.
“All the best of me belongs to her –
there is not a talent, or an aspiration or a joy in me that has not been
awakened by her loving touch.”
Hellen Keller is a child who has been rendered deaf and blind
since an unfortunate illness struck her in her childhood.
She lived in a dark and isolated world. Even Specialists
couldn’t help her out. Captain and Mrs.
Keller seemed to have lost all hope, and then arrived Anne Sullivan. This
teacher was the final hope for The Kellers who seemed resigned to sending Helen
off to an asylum.
Helen in one of her mad rages knocks out her teacher’s tooth
and slaps her across the cheek on multiple occasions. Despite this she stays
on, she recognises that the student should not be labelled as bad but as
challenging.
Anne Sullivan discovers that Helen first needs to be taught
discipline, she knows that the girl’s frustrations need to be checked. Sullivan
does not take pity on Helen and battles with her physically (bordering on child
abuse) and emotionally (separating Helen from her family for 2 weeks) until she
finally makes a breakthrough.
3. Aamir Khan as Ram Shankar Nikumbh
(Taare Zameen Par)
Every child is special, but that is not understood by all
9 year old Ishaan Avasthi is misunderstood everywhere and is
subjected to thrashings, verbal abuse. He gets shipped off to boarding school
as his parents think that his mistakes are not mistakes but acts of rebellion.
At his new school, things do not change. He retreats further into his shell and
his spirit is broken. The 9 year old now has lifeless eyes and attends class
like a robot.
When all hope seems lost, there enters a new art teacher (Ram
Shankar Nikumbh). This teacher is different from the rest of the teachers as he
doesn’t stamp his authority on the class through fear but gets the students to
like him through his unconventional methods. As is the norm with Bollywood
films, there are no dialogues but a wonderful song sung by the teacher that
encourages children to look at things in a different way. Ishaan however has
been scarred so badly that he stops painting. Nikumbh doesn’t seem to mind and
he tries to befriend the boy. According to Nikumbh, “every child has his own
talent.” Nikumbh finds out that Ishaan’s talent lies in art. The teacher then
realises what Ishaan’s disorder is and how it can be countered.
Nikumbh brings out the boys potential through art by teaching
him alphabets and numbers through art. In a bid to boost Ishaan’s self-confidence,
an all school painting competition is organised.
At the end Mr Avasthi is reduced to tears after seeing his son’s
transformation wonders how he can thank the teacher. Nikumbh replies nonchalantly
with an, “ah c’mon,” as he was just doing his duty as a teacher.
"Either you Karate
do yes, or Karate do no. You Karate do guess so you get squish, just like
grape."
The words of Keisuke Miyagi are reminiscent of Master Yoda's
words from Star Wars. Do or do not there is no try.
We have to learn to take a stand. By acting confused and
being in two minds we will neither be here nor there. Imagine you are walking
on the road, you either take left side or right side, if you are unsure and
walk in centre you will be hit.
We need 100% belief in our own set goals in order to achieve
them.
Mr Miyagi saves Daniel LaRusso from a bunch of bullies (The
Cobra Kai). As a trade for getting them to lay off him for a while. Mr Miyagi
enters Daniel into a Karate Tournament and also trains him for the same. He has
one rule-ask no questions. Mr Miyagi makes Daniel do what seems like household
work (waxing the car, scrubbing the floor, painting the fence and the house)
with particular hand movements. Just as Daniel is about to quit as he is sick
and tired of his “karate lessons” Mr Miyagi explains and demonstrates the
importance of those tasks to karate.
We then need to believe in the methods of the teacher. They
know what the long term goal is. Mr Miyagi, by making Daniel do what seemed
like menial household tasks actually imbibed in him the karate movements as
natural actions. This style of teaching is not looked at favourably by the student
as they want to know why a particular thing is being taught. However we must realise
that the teacher is not stupid and doesn’t have time to waste, they also
realise that the student has no time to waste and whatever is being taught is
for the students benefit.
Another important lesson given here is “first learn walk then
learn fly.” It emphasises the need to learn things step by step.
While these actors and actresses pretend for a living, this
pretend is based on true stories. Real life isn’t like a movie where the story
ends after one success.
The movies end on a high and we assume that it's over. Real
life inspires films but what films don't show is that there is so much more
effort that a teacher puts in, sometimes even until their death.
The Miracle worker (the only film in this list based on a
true story) didn’t mention anything about what happened after Helen Keller Anne
Sullivan made a breakthrough in the climax. After teaching Helen Keller the
meaning of alphabets and words, Anne Sullivan stayed with Helen for the next 49
years until her death.
The job of a teacher in real life goes back to square one
once the next batch comes in. Their stories don't end like how Mr Miyagi’s
story ended with Daniel LaRusso winning the tournament. The Mr Miyagi of real
life have another Daniel LaRusso and then another and then another and another
and another. They have to approach each and every single student with the same
level of passion as the first.
There are some teachers who also try and try, but the outcome
isn’t like a fairy tale as seen in the above movies. That doesn’t demean the
efforts put in by these teachers.
Though the end result may not be as desirable as shown in the
movies, but, the effort put in by every single teacher is what we should see
and learn from these movies, which can be seen as tributes to the efforts taken
by a teacher.
Honourable mentions: Shahrukh Khan as Raj Malhotra from
Mohabattein and as Kabir Khan from Chak De! India, Burgess Meredith as Mickey
Goldmill from Rocky, Julie Andrews as Maria Von Trapp from The Sound of Music.
No comments:
Post a Comment